Andrew Root on children and divorce. Chilling.
April 5, 2011 1 Comment
In the documentary film One Divided by Two: Kids and Divorce, there is an animated scene that relays the haunting dream of a child after the divorce of his parents. The narrator begins:
When my parents first divorced I was scared that my parents would both start new families and forget about me. Around this time I had a dream. It was Christmas and we were all doing our shopping. I had some money to go and buy my parents and family some gifts. All of a sudden, out of the corner of my eye I see my mother. I was so happy to see her that I decided to run up to her and give her a big hug and then wish her a merry Christmas. My mother was with two other children, and I kept calling her, “Mommy, Mommy.” But she didn’t even know who I was; she was calling the little children her little children, and they were calling her “Mommy.” I felt so strange and awkward, I had seen my mother in a different family, and she didn’t even recognize me.
‘This dream reveals the ontological ramifications of divorce. This child’s dream communicates the questions of being he faces as he confronts the loss of a familial community. As he thinks about the divorce of his parents, his deepest fear is that in their division they will start new families. In these families and communities he is a stranger and, as such, worries that his being will be forgotten. If he is in the midst of acting with and for these people, if he has his being in the midst of this family, what will it mean for him (what will it mean for his being) if they depart to start new families? The children born into this new family will be elected through the union of parent and stepparent (they will have biological correlation to both parents), but this boy will be part of this new family onlythrough choice. He can depart the new family at any time to live with the other parent (or grandparent, etc.). In this back-and-forth of choice, this boy wonders whether between one family and the next he might get lost or, rather, feels, ontologically, like he is lost. This new family will be forever tenuous for him, for his being is not the outgrowth of it. He is there only by “choice” (choice of his parent or his own choice.
In this community, this new family, he is ontologically different, for his being is not bound to both parents, but only to one, and this one-in this instance, his mother-has cleaved her being to others that have no direct connection to the boy. Will she remember him and the way they were together? Will she honor their connection? And if she forgets or denies it, then who is the boy? How can he be? He worries so deeply about this that his unconscious communicates it to him in a dream in which his mommy has other children and forgets, ignores, or, more radically, negates his being. His being, in his dream, has become a stranger to her own. He calls her “Mommy!” from the core of his being, but now with these other children and family all around her, she cannot see him. His plea is a deep ontological cry (as object relations psychology has told us, and as we will see below), but the dream-mother returns his longing for community (for being-with, being connected to the origins of his being) with nothing but confusion, for her being is now connected to others.
– Children of Divorce, The: The Loss of Family as the Loss of Being (Andrew Root)


★★★★★